A Halloween Thriller: Dodgers’ Game 5 Comeback and the Win Probability Rollercoaster

There I was, decked out in Star Trek Lower Decks costume at a Yelp Halloween party, watching Game 5 of the World Series on a massive LEDTV at Funburger in Valencia. It was a classic LA night – costumes everywhere, drinks flowing, and a crowd of Dodgers fans all clinging to the edge of hope. In fact, I left home when the Dodgers looked to have been had by the Yankees because of a struggling Flaherty. We watched with bated breath, glued to every pitch, every swing, and every heart-stopping moment of what felt like the longest game of our lives. This win probability chart? It’s not just numbers – it’s a visual of every gut-wrenching swing in emotion that we lived through that night.

Win Probability Chart by Sara Langs (@SlangsOnSports) https://x.com/SlangsOnSports/status/1851836273146622442

The Game in Numbers: A Win Probability Analysis

The Early Game: Yankees Crush Our Hopes

As the game kicked off, I was at home, all of us, my son, my wife, and I had a good feeling we’d bring this home today. But as Aaron Judge and Jazz Chisholm Jr. each hit their home runs, we found ourselves stunned and frustrated. The Yankees quickly pushed their lead to 5-0, gone were the “yessss!” and in were the “Dammit Dodgers, why you gotta break our hearts every October?” That massive dip on the win probability chart? Yeah, that was all of us Dodger fans looking around, wide-eyed, wondering if we’d see a comeback or if our Halloween night would end in heartbreak. The Yankees’ win probability surged to over 85% by the end of the third inning, and for a moment, we all feared it was over.

Mid-Game Shift: Errors Give Us a Glimmer of Hope

The text the changed it all.

Just as we were beginning to feel the sting of impending loss, I was getting dressed to head off to a party in Valencia hosted by Yelp. Driving there, I got a fun little phone notification. Glancing down while driving, I saw “Aaron Judge” and thought, “Welp, he’s gonna nail the coffin in”, considering he’d been awoken from his power hitting slump slumber. It wasn’t until a long traffic light I was able to read the rest of the notification, “YANKEES DEFENSIVE MELTDOWN” it said in bold letters and I laughed like Joaquin Phoenix’s Joker. The fifth inning brought a glimmer of hope. Aaron Judge, who had just thrilled Yankees fans with his home run, dropped a routine fly ball, giving us a spark. Then Anthony Volpe followed with a throwing error, and suddenly, the energy shifted. Each tiny win probability bump represented another wave of cheers in the bar, as hope crept back into our Halloween celebration. Small mistakes, yes, but in baseball, they’re game-changers. That slow, upward climb on the chart mirrored our mood – hesitant, cautious, but ready to believe in a comeback.

The Turning Point: Mookie Betts Seals the Deal

Dodger fans in Baited Breath

By the eighth inning, the tension was unbearable. The Dodgers had clawed their way back to a tie, and every fan in the bar was watching with wide-eyed anticipation. Then came the moment: Mookie Betts stepped up and drove in the game-winning run with a sacrifice fly. The bar erupted. People in costumes were hugging, high-fiving, and chanting. The win probability chart shot up in the Dodgers’ favor, and so did our spirits. This wasn’t just another game; this was a comeback for the ages. We could feel the victory.

The win probability spike in the final innings reflects the overwhelming excitement we felt in that moment. By the ninth inning, it was clear: the Dodgers were about to pull off a Halloween miracle.

Getting Nerdy with the Data: What Win Probability Tells Us

For a data nerd like me, win probability isn’t just a line – it’s a storytelling device that captures every single twist and turn. Here’s what we’re seeing when we break down this particular chart:

  1. Historical Data at Work: This chart uses decades of data on similar situations to tell us the odds of winning at any given moment. So when the Yankees had that big 5-0 lead, the numbers were against us. But the moment those errors happened, we could see the shift. Each little uptick was a reminder that baseball is a game of possibilities – and even a big lead isn’t safe.
  2. The Impact of Errors: Every play, especially errors, carries weight in the model. Judge’s dropped ball and Volpe’s errant throw weren’t just mistakes; they were pivotal moments that helped shift the odds back in our favor. In win probability terms, they represented a tangible, measurable change in momentum, and every Dodgers fan in that bar felt it.
  3. Momentum Builds Slowly… Until It Doesn’t: Notice how the Dodgers’ win probability doesn’t leap instantly after each play. Instead, it’s a gradual rise. This is baseball at its finest – every small play, every single base runner, every inning adds pressure until it bursts. When Betts drove in that final run, the probability spiked, capturing the culmination of steady, resilient play.
  4. The Ninth-Inning Seal: That final surge on the chart shows the moment when victory was all but certain. For those of us watching in costume, it was the point where we started to celebrate, knowing we’d pulled off a comeback worthy of the history books.

The Emotional Rollercoaster: Living Through the Chart

This game was more than numbers – it was the embodiment of resilience. As Dodgers fans, we went from stunned silence to tentative hope, to full-blown euphoria. The win probability chart doesn’t just show who won; it captures the journey, the tension, and the sweet release when we finally broke through. In those final innings, we experienced the highs and lows that make baseball magical, all within the compressed space of a Halloween party where strangers became family for a night.

The Dodgers’ performance showed us that win probability, much like life, isn’t set in stone. Sometimes you’re down, the odds are stacked against you, and the data says you’re done. But baseball – and maybe life too – is about those moments when grit and belief can shift the odds.

Final Thoughts

Game 5 was a Halloween thriller, a night where sports data met raw emotion. For the Dodgers and every fan watching, this win probability chart is a symbol of resilience, a testament to the power of hanging in there when the chips are down. And as for those of us in the bar, surrounded by costumes and a sea of blue, it was a night we’ll never forget – one where the numbers told us it was over, but we knew the Dodgers weren’t done yet.

Here’s to the Dodgers, to win probability charts that make us sweat, and to all the unexpected heroes that make baseball the best game in the world. Happy Halloween, LA – and congrats to our Dodgers!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *